Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Mariah Cressy
Chairman's Club & Circle of Excellence 2025
REALTOR®
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon VCard Icon 

Customer Reviews

testimonial quote

Mariah is the best! She stayed on top of all communication with other realtors/vendors/inspectors and consistently relayed information to us. Most importantly, she provided professional expertise when asked but did not pressue to make any decisions that we were not comfortable with. Much of our sale process happened with us at a distance and she jumped in when necessary and kept things on track. Highly recommend!

Scott Kachmarik, Pickerington, OH | Home Seller
testimonial quote

When our first realtor did not meet our expectations, Mariah was recommended to us. She was so much more helpful in our home search and even found homes similar to the one we were looking at to just so we have an understanding of the market. Her professionalism and communication are unmatched.

Ian Beiersdorf, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was great to work with: * very responsive to messages * very accessible and able to meet with us on short notice and at odd hours * very knowledge about the local area and the process * well-connected with service providers

Kirsten Kish, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I have been working with Mariah for many years now, through both the sale and purchase of homes and lots. She is responsive, knowledgeable, and very, very patient. Very patient. 10/10, would highly recommend!

Shaun Burrell, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I cannot recommend Mariah Crecy highly enough! From our very first conversation, she was incredibly attentive to all of our needs and made the entire home-buying process smooth and stress-free. Mariah was always quick to respond to our questions and kept us informed every step of the way. Her excellent communication skills and dedication truly set her apart. Thanks to Mariah’s expertise and hard work, we are now in our dream home! She went above and beyond to ensure we found exactly what we were looking for, and we couldn’t be happier with the results. If you’re looking for a realtor who is professional, responsive, and genuinely cares about getting you into the perfect home, Mariah is the one to call!

Killian Probst, Mishawaka IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy was fantastic and did everything necessary to get my house sold quickly. She was always available to answer questions and constantly put my mind at ease. Selling with Mariah was a very pleasant experience and I will use her again in a few months when my daughter begins the process of selling her house. I really can't say enough good things about my favorite realtor!

Jan Werth, Mishawaka, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy is an absolute marvel. Although I happened to know that she had a lot of personal things going on during our home buying and selling process, you would never have known based on how responsive, helpful, and professional she was throughout. She thoughtfully explains every piece of the complex real estate process, does not apply pressure on her clients, and is fully committed to helping the people she represents get what is most important to them. Her attention to detail is seriously impressive, and she is just a delightful person to work with. Mariah is absolutely someone you want on your side- kind and professional, but also a skilled negotiator who understands the real estate market incredibly well.

Caitlin, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Very grateful highly recommend.

Michael R Mitcheff, Mishawaka, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy was friendly, responsive, knowledgable and well connected. We would happily rely on her again if we were selling in the area.

Dan Nolan, Santa Cruz, CA | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah was incredibly helpful and played a vital role throughout my home buying journey. She took the time to clearly explain real estate concepts I wasn’t familiar with and was consistently communicative and readily available at every step. I would highly recommend her to anyone navigating the home purchase process.

Gisele, Granger, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Ms. Cressy worked hard to find what we wanted in South Bend. She was always responsive and gave 110% effort. I would recommend her highly.

Cristos Goodrow, Burlingame, CA | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy is really good at her job. She is efficient, organized, and thorough. Mariah answers my questions thoughtfully. She is a genuine pleasure to work with and she makes this sometimes-stressful process fun! I have worked with her in the past and will continue to call her when I need a real estate agent! I would confidently recommend Mariah to anyone who is going to buy or sell a house. Thank you, Mariah!

Amy Fulkerson, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We loved working with Mariah! She was very knowledgeable and professional in assisting us as first time home buyers. She worked to answer all of our questions in a timely manner and provided great recommendations for companies to work with for the inspections. She even handled coordinating our furnace replacement even after closing. We will definitely be recommending Mariah to family and friends!

Michael and Tiara Cartwright, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah worked very hard for us and shared her expert knowledge during every step along the way.

Jared Dees, Granger, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy is everything you would want in a real estate agent. She was kind, professional and very knowledgeable. Always quick to respond to any questions or concerns. Took a lot of the stress out of selling a house. I would recommend her to our closest friends and family.

Matthew Pazderka, South Bend, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah is the epitome of a professional with superb knowledge of the marketplace. We also had a need to engage a real estate lawyer and appreciate her contacts in the community. If buying or selling, one could work with no better agent than Mariah.

Syd Young, Alexandria VA | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Working with Mariah Cressy made my family's home search and buying process truly seamless. She was highly professional, always accessible, and brought an impressive depth of knowledge about the South Bend area. Her expert advice and exceptional negotiation skills helped us secure our first family home, which exceeded all our expectations. We highly recommend Mariah to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in South Bend or the surrounding areas!

Jacob Allen, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was detailed, thorough, and on-point. She was extremely professional and was very good at her job. However, what stuck out the most to us was the time and care she took to get to know our family and what we needed in a home. We never felt rushed as she was committed to finding us the perfect fit on our time. When it came time to buy our new home and sell our old home, she was incredibly strategic in the negotiations. Her knowledge of the market trends allowed us to put forward the most competitive bid we could, and inevitably got us our new home. Then, Mariah turned around and aggressively marketed the sale of our new home, which led to us selling the house on the same day it hit the market, and for 10% above our asking price. Mariah is professional, responsive, savvy, and kind. Not much more you could ask for in an agent. Our family is grateful for her hard work and her friendship.

Jared Mrozinske, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah is incredible!

Brad Emberton, SouthBend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy is an absolutely amazing realtor, and I cannot recommend her highly or often enough. She is incredibly knowledgeable and a real professional, and she uses her knowledge to help her clients make the best home purchase possible for them. She helped us make an early, appropriately aggressive offer to get us into our dream home. She is simply the best!

Angela Schwenkler, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy was extremely well prepared for her initial presentation to us. She was able to explain the multiple steps and complexities of the process in a clear and easy to understand manner. She was careful to determine our particular wants and needs throughout the process, but was also able to guide and direct us where needed. She was on top of everything and responded almost immediately to every text or telephone call regardless of day or time. She coordinated interactions with buyer's agents extremely effectively and kept us informed throughout. Her unfailingly positive, confident, and optimistic attitude reassured us. Mariah's bright and pleasant personality was a bright spot in a trying process. She was a pleasure to work with and the results of her efforts exceeded our expectations.

Brad Eaton, Granger, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah worked with us first in 3/23 and again in 3/24. The interruption was on our side. Her knowledge of the local market was very important due to the market changes during tumultuous economic times with high interest rates! She was professional, available and walked us step by step through the process. Would highly recommend whether buying or selling a home in the area.

Sharon Burden, Mishawaka, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah was incredible. She worked quick and efficiently. Always available for everything, and did all she could to help us out in every way she could during the home-buying process. We appreciated Mariah's awesome attitude, patience, and willingness to help us find our home!

Nathan Rolf, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was incredibly professional yet sensitive and understating of our situation. She guided us through each step with patience. From the moment I spoke to her, I trusted that she would do the best she could for us. This was particularly important as we are based abroad.

NB, UK | Home Seller
testimonial quote

There are no words to describe how great Mariah is at her job. She did an absolutely phenomenal job for us. She knew the answer to everything we asked. She was always willing to help us. We moved from out of state and there were a ton of hurdles and things we were unfamiliar with. Mariah took care of everything and more. She's above anyone else we've ever worked with and its not even close. Buying and selling homes can be very stressful, but she made it as easy as possible for us. We are incredibly grateful and thankful, and will definitely be returning as customers in the future.

Charlie, Osceola IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was extremely diligent and responsive in all aspects of the process. She went above and beyond in being helpful to us as first time homebuyers and understanding all steps.

Paul Ogren, Chicago, IL | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah has a lot of patience with a hard people like me. and work so hard to find what We was looking for. Mariah Cressy, Thank You so much for treat! We're so much grateful to you. She makes us feel like part of her family.

Marcos Mireles south bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We are always impressed with Mariah Cressy's knowledge, attention to detail, communication skills, and responsiveness. We would highly recommend her services to anyone who appreciates excellence.

Georgia Spalding, Berrien Springs | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

We could not have asked for a better experience or a better agent. Mariah was truly outstanding. By far the best agent we've ever had.

Bob & Susan, Granger IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I really can't say enough good things about our experience working with Mariah Cressy, both in buying a house and selling a house. We were not the easiest clients, but Mariah was always helpful, patient, knowledgeable, and fun to work with. I always felt like she was a teammate, and she made the complicated process of buying and selling a house go smoothly.

Kristina, South Bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

It was a pleasure working with Mariah and she will be the person that I refer to my friends and family if they are interested in selling or buying a house in the SB/Mishawaka area. Her response times, attention to detail and overall helpfulness was outstanding.

Josip Galic, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

She truly had every detail perfect. Drummed up excitement around the property. We had a completely full first day of showings! Mariah is incredibly detail oriented. She understood exactly what we wanted in a sale and buyer. She was very communicative and responsive to us, as well as our buyers. An excellent experience.

Bridget & Steve Group | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah is wonderful. She truly understands her buyers wants and needs. I cannot recommend her enough! Very detailed oriented and very proactive in communications. Kept us apprised of all happenings and her expectations of us. Thank you, Mariah!

Bridget & Steve Group, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah is extremely professional, knowledgeable honest, and trustworthy. She worked hard to ensure that everything was taken care of effortlessly. Would recommend with my highest regards!

John Paul L, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

very very good at what she is doing. she was excellent

Larry Peak south bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah was extremely patient with us in a fast paced and wild real estate market. Once we finally decided to list our house, Mariah had a plan that made the process seamless from the date of listing, until closing. Her guidance and negotiations with prospective buyers and their offers was top notch. Mariah ensured that we maximized our sales price and the value of our home, in a multiple offer situation. Once we had an accepted offer, Mariah made the process simple to get to closing and provided us with weekly updates on where everything stood and items that needed completed. Mariah made it easy to still our house.

Adam & Carly Schwelnus | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We enjoyed a stress free and streamlined for experience when we listed and sold our home with Mariah Cressy. She accurately estimated the appraised value to price our home competitively, advised us on our marketing strategy to lather up the marketplace, coordinated a weekend resulting in 41 listings and 17 offers, and lastly helped us negotiate and settle in the highest value offer for our home. We couldn't be happier with the results and we highly recommend Mariah to all of our friends, family, and acquaintances.

Ray Korson, Granger, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

If you're looking for a real estate professional who knows the local market inside and out and takes the time to thoroughly understand your needs, look no further than Mariah Cressy. Mariah patiently worked with us for over 18 months as we looked for the right home for our family. When it came time to buy, Mariah and her team were fully accessible to us and helped us structure an offer that stood apart in a competitive market. After the sale, she supported us right up to the closing table, keeping us organized and providing timely advice throughout. We couldn't be happier with our experience and we recommend that you talk to Mariah right away if you are looking for a trusted agent.

Ray and Mary Korson, Granger, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah took care of me better than any other Real Estate can.

Bill McDonald Mishawaka Indiana | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was amazing, I’m so grateful for all she did to make my experience as a first time homebuyer smooth and easy. She was knowledgeable, available, and helped me feel comfortable throughout the entire process. Would highly recommend to anyone buying a home!

Maggie Cressy, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

As the transaction coordinator for the sale of my rental property, Mariah Cressy made the entire process extremely simple! I appreciated her sound advice when it came to gathering comps and setting a sales price. Every step along the way, she was quick to respond to questions from both myself and the buyer - even in the midst of welcoming a new baby to her family! Highly recommend Mariah for any real estate sales/buying needs. I know without a doubt I'll be using her again!

Erin, South Bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy did an amazing job helping my fiancé and I buy our first house! She was readily available to look at houses, had great tips and advice about the house buying experience, made our transaction so easy and painless, and was very professional! I would recommend Mariah for anybody looking for a broker! Mariah was very personable and outgoing. It was truly a pleasure to work with Mariah Cressy who had all of the answers to our real estate questions!

Lauren Beebe, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

I have known Mariah for several years, and know what a brilliant and hard working individual she is. She went above and beyond for me and I could not be more satisfied with the services she provided.

John Spalding, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

The sale of our house was a roller coaster ride because of the other party. Mariah was on the ball with everything. She went to bat for us before I even had to tell her to. She had our best interest in mind the whole time. From giving us advice on how to list to understanding offers being made. If it wasn't for Mariah I'm sure I would of had an even more rough time selling this. Thank you for everything you did for us!

Jim Cassoday - Valparaiso | Home Seller
testimonial quote

The entire went smoothly, mostly as we expected it to, and we're very happy with our experience with Mariah, and would recommend her 10/10 times.

Jessica, Winding Brook Park | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We were first-time home buyers with some very specific demands, buying in an extremely difficult market. Mariah Cressy guided us through the process skillfully, and she found us a wonderful house that met all of our needs. We highly recommend Mariah as a realtor!

Tawrin Baker, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

My husband and I enlisted Mariah for help with the sale of our first family home and the purchase of our new forever home this Spring. We reached out to Mariah a bit out of the blue, and frankly, we were probably very high-needs clients, as there were many unusual and complicated steps we had to get through for our situation, but Mariah helped us every step of the way and was extremely patient with and responsive to every question we had. Mariah helped us get our house ready to list within 48 hours of our first chat. We had a successful weekend of jam-packed showings, which resulted in several offers being written, and us walking away with an accepted offer that was well over our list price. Mariah then helped us negotiate an offer for our forever home, and helped us navigate all of the bumps in the road until we finally made it to closing for both transactions. Mariah sent helpful reminders to ensure every deadline was met and all aspects of both transactions proceeded smoothly. She was professional, kind, trustworthy, and always timely. We are thankful we chose to use Mariah to sell and buy our homes, and would absolutely recommend her to anyone considering selling or buying a home in this area in the future!

Dani Weiss, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah was simply fantastic. We were 1st time home buyers and experiencing all the anxiety that comes along with it. She was informative, patient and understanding. We closed earlier than expected and the entire process took less than 30 days. I Can’t speak highly enough about Mariah’s work ethic, knowledge and professionalism. She was extremely efficient in finding us our dream home and I would highly recommend her services to anyone looking to buy a house. She worked closely with the sellers and their team to make sure all of our needs were met. She helped answer all of our questions Throughout the application and closing process.

Matt, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy did an excellent job in helping me find my first home! She was professional and understood my needs and wants. Her knowledge about the process made me feel comfortable and confident that I can rely on her. I would recommend Mariah Cressy to future homeowners!

Caitlin Stotler - South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mariah Cressy is very professional. Mariah was Extremely helpful, friendly and polite. Very knowledgeable. She made the process very simple, step by step.

Dylan Damiani, Osceola | Home Buyer
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 04/23/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 04/23/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Thu 04/23/2026 10:20:26 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Thu 04/23/2026 10:18:47 AM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Thu 04/23/2026 10:15:01 AM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Thu 04/23/2026 10:17:42 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Mariah Cressy is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Indiana.

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel